This cake began with me flipping through my well-loved copy of Tartine’s first cookbook and finding myself suddenly intrigued by their recipe for caramel apples. Up until then, I had never had a caramel apple. I had never wanted a caramel apple. I had never understood why anyone would want an apple dunked in sweet, sticky goo. But for whatever reason, because my brain is the way it is, I suddenly very much wanted a caramel apple. And not just any caramel apple, but Tartine’s caramel apples.
So… why not make an entire cake to go with it? Let’s break it down:
- Cake: Lightly spiced cake studded with fresh apple chunks
- Filling: Italian buttercream whipped with tangy sour cream and honey
- Outer: Italian buttercream
- Topping: Tart and buttery apple cider caramel
All together, you get a cake that just bursts with proper apple goodness.